A local county councillor has called ‘blanket bans’ on some of Pembrokeshire’s beaches ‘overly punitive on dog owners’ as members of the Local Authority back trialling a new way of enforcing seasonal bylaws.

The seasonal ban on some of the county’s beaches, which includes Tenby’s North and Castle beaches, as well as part of South beach runs between May 1 and September 30.

At Pembrokeshire County Council’s Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting on March 27, members heard a council Task and Finish Group meeting had discussed updating the current procedure.

“Based on feedback received by members from users both residents and visitors, the view of the group was that a level of enforcement was required but to undertake a trial surrounding a blended approach associated with the issues of warnings for first-time offenders, combined with the issuing of fixed penalty notices where appropriate.”

It added: “This is only for dogs on beaches; dog fouling on the street and beach will continue to be enforced.”

It was recommended to take a three-fold approach - improvements in communication and visibility of the dog-free zones through a review of signage and visibility of enviro-crime officers; reviewing bylaws; and the trial of a new procedure surrounding the enforcement of dogs on beaches for 2025.

Regarding the dogs on beaches trial, the report for members said there would be an “intelligence-led” approach tackling “hot-spots”.

If individuals are found with dogs within a restricted area, enviro-crime enforcement officers will undertake the following:

• Engage with the dog owners, issue a warning – full contact details will be taken.

• Dog owner will be requested to walk away from the restricted area – failing to do so will result in a FPN being issued.

• Dog owners will be asked to put their dog on a lead – failure to do so will result in a FPN being issued.

• Second offence after a warning will result in a FPN being issued.

• Dog fouling – FPN will be issued.

It concluded: “The view of the task and finish group was these measures would enable a trial season where education is given priority over enforcement, which could then be compared with the 2024 season of full enforcement.

“This will enable the committee to assess the two operating models when reviewed following the 2025 season.”

Speaking at the meeting, Cllr Rhys Jordan moved the recommendation, but said “blanket bans” on some of the county’s beaches were “overly punitive on dog owners,” adding: “Responsible owners do look after their dogs, but unfortunately it is the small minority; to have six or seven months of the year that certain beaches are completely banned from dogs is a bit much in my view.”

Committee chair Cllr Mark Carter said: “70% of those caught with dogs are tourists, I really think we’re sending out the wrong message; giving a warning is fair in my mind, it’s good for business and good for tourism; I’m very grateful to officers for getting this to this level.”

Members agreed to back the recommendations of the task and finish group.